Tuesday, October 4, 2022
HomeRetirementReader Case: Ought to I Rollover my 401(Ok)?

Reader Case: Ought to I Rollover my 401(Ok)?

Photograph: 401k ira roth on items of colourful sticky paper on desk by Marco Verch beneath Artistic Commons 2.0

Earlier than we get began on at the moment’s reader case, we simply needed to let you recognize that we’ll be attending the Journey Summit in Toronto from Oct 28-29, 2022! If need to come, you should utilize our affiliate code “MILLENNIAL” to get $50 off: https://thetravelsummit.com/#tickets

Now onward to the reader case!

At this time’s reader case poses an fascinating dilemma that isn’t typical of our traditional early retiree questions, so I used to be instantly intrigued. Test it out, yo!

Hello Firecracker & Wanderer,

I not too long ago left my job and will use your steering to determine whether or not to rollover my 401k to an IRA or not. My new job doesn’t have a 401k plan.

My 401k has each Pre-tax and Roth contributions in it. Primarily based on some web studying, it appears like the primary drawback of doing the rollover could be that I can now not do a straight ahead Backdoor Roth contribution due to the pro-rata rule.

With the intention to perceive the implications of every aspect, in millennial-revolution type, I made a decision to “math shit up”. 

Pre-tax: $314,536.42

Roth: $127,055.17
Return Price: 8%
Years to Retirement: 20
Tax Price: 37%


Rollover Tax: $116,378.48

Roth Complete After Rollover: $325,213.11

Worth at Retirement: $1,861,764.84

No Rollover

401k Charges: 0.10%

Pre-tax Worth at Retirement: $1,439,129.36

Tax on Withdrawal: $532,477.86

Roth Worth at Retirement: $581,327.99

Worth at Retirement: $1,487,979.49

Assuming that I’ll proceed to be within the highest tax bracket at retirement (spouse needs to proceed working + passive earnings sources), it appears like I’d be higher off doing the rollover and persevering with to benefit from the Backdoor Roth contributions.

Not doing a rollover appears to be higher if my tax bracket at retirement drops to 11%. 

Thanks for every little thing you do. I actually take pleasure in studying your blogs often and thought this was an excellent alternative for me to say thanks and presumably contribute to the weblog and neighborhood as I’m pretty positive many others face the identical query.


OK that is much less of a standard reader case and extra of a tax query. Let’s do a fast recap of the technique he’s referring to.

Most individuals are conversant in Roth IRAs as a tax-sheltered method to save for retirement. You’ll be able to contribute as much as $6000 ($7000 should you’re over 50) a 12 months and it grows tax-free without end. In contrast to conventional IRAs which drive you to withdraw taxable distributions while you hit a sure age, no such pressured withdrawals occur with Roth IRAs.

Roths do have a little bit of a quirk although. For some cause, the US authorities restricts the power to make a contribution should you earn an excessive amount of cash.

I’ve at all times thought that was such a dumb rule. Serving to your residents save for his or her retirement is at all times an excellent factor, because it means they’re much less prone to be destitute and are available begging to the federal government for a handout later, but this rule discourages higher-income households for no good cause. Comparable accounts in different nations like Canada’s RRSP or the UK’s ISA don’t have earnings limits, so on this regard America stands out as an outlier.

Luckily, there’s a method to get round this limitation. You’ll be able to elect to make a non-deductible contribution to a standard IRA, which suggests you’ll be able to’t deduct it out of your taxable earnings. Usually, you by no means need to do that because you’re forfeiting the primary tax benefit of utilizing a standard IRA, however should you do that after which switch the non-deductible contributions over to a Roth IRA, you’ve successfully bypassed the earnings limits on the Roth.

It is a technique often known as the Backdoor Roth IRA contribution, and I wrote up an extended and extra detailed clarification right here.

How Does a 401K Rollover Have an effect on Them?

Our reader can be asking about doing a 401(ok) rollover, which is one thing you are able to do too while you go away an employer. Mainly, you’ll be able to fill out some paperwork and have your 401(ok) steadiness transferred or “curler over” into a standard IRA account that you just open by yourself. This fashion, you don’t have to go away your retirement financial savings together with your previous employer, which simplifies your accounts in addition to doubtlessly saves on charges.

Nonetheless, this may increasingly affect the power to do backdoor Roth IRA conversions going ahead.

The explanation for this can be a tremendous annoying IRS rule known as the Professional-Rata rule.

Mainly, in case your conventional IRA has each pre-tax and post-tax contributions, withdrawals are taxed based mostly on how a lot of every was in your account earlier than the withdrawal. For instance, let’s say your conventional IRA had $50k in it, and $45k of it was from pre-tax deductible contributions and $5k was from post-tax non-deductible contributions.

For those who tried to switch $5k out of your conventional IRA to your Roth IRA hoping that the contribution could be untaxed because it was out of your post-tax contributions, the IRS would declare that as a result of your IRA had 90% pre-tax and 10% post-tax contributions in it, the 90% of the $5k switch, or $4,500, could be thought of a pre-tax withdrawal, and subsequently taxed as common earnings.

Your withdrawals are taxed proportionally, or pro-rata, to the pre- and post-tax make-up of your conventional IRA, therefore the title.

Why does this should be so sophisticated? I do not know. It’s the IRS!

Regardless, that signifies that any pre-tax contributions to a standard IRA “pollute” it and makes future backdoor Roth IRA contributions much less tax environment friendly.

What Ought to Our Reader Do?

OK so just a few issues are fascinating about our reader’s scenario right here.

To start with, he’s anticipating to be in a excessive tax bracket in retirement, which isn’t often how retirement works. Usually, while you retire your earned earnings drops to 0, which signifies that you’re in no hazard of hitting the Roth IRA earnings ranges that restrict contributions. You’ll be able to simply contribute the max yearly.

Nonetheless, our reader’s spouse, apparently, is planning on persevering with to work, and on high of that she apparently makes fairly a bit as a result of to ensure that the Roth IRA’s contributions to be eradicated the annual earnings of the household needs to be above $200k. I feel this technically makes her a Sugar Mamma. Good.

So what meaning is that he ought to not rollover his 401(ok) right into a Conventional IRA. The minute he does that, the IRA turns into polluted with deductible contributions, and if he makes an attempt to do a backdoor Roth contribution later, the dreaded pro-rate guidelines would kick in since he’d have each pre-tax and post-tax contributions in his IRA.

So if he’s frightened about preserving his means to make Backdoor Roth contributions after retirement, he ought to go away his 401(ok) alone along with his previous employer.

One other factor that’s fascinating is that he’s shifting from a job that provides a 401(ok) to 1 that doesn’t. Within the US, it’s as much as every particular person employer to determine whether or not they need to provide a 401(ok) plan, but when your employer doesn’t provide one, you’ll be able to nonetheless open up your personal IRA and contribute to it your self.

Nonetheless, he shouldn’t do that.

As soon as once more, as quickly as he makes a pre-tax contribution to his conventional IRA account, it turns into “polluted” and may now not do tax-free backdoor Roth contributions in retirement. What he ought to do as an alternative is barely make non-deductible contributions to his Conventional IRA, then convert them annually to his Roth IRA as soon as he begins his new job.

Granted that this implies he’s going to overlook out on these candy candy tax deductions whereas he’s working, however it’s the one method to hold his IRA account “clear.”

Nonetheless, that’s to not say he has to go away every little thing in his 401(ok). He has a 401(ok) that may maintain each each conventional pre-tax and Roth post-tax contributions, and it appears like he’s made each forms of contributions through the years.

A Roth 401(ok) will also be rolled over, although quite than transferring it to a standard IRA like a standard 401(ok), it will as an alternative go right into a Roth IRA account. This wouldn’t have an effect on the pro-rata rule because it solely applies to the steadiness in your Conventional IRA. So this fashion, he can save at the least a part of the 401(ok) plan’s administration charges.

So mainly, he ought to do that…

Doing this could give him the utmost tax advantages whereas preserving the power to do tax-free backdoor Roth IRA contributions going ahead.

And as at all times, our reader ought to seek the advice of with a tax skilled earlier than implementing something as a result of I could not have all of the related details about his private tax scenario.

So what do you suppose? Is that this probably the most optimum construction for our reader, or is there one thing else he ought to do as an alternative? Let’s hear it within the feedback under!

Announcement: We’ll be attending the Journey Summit in Toronto from Oct 28-29, 2022!

If you wish to find out about journey hacking and methods to fly top notch and keep in luxurious resorts at no cost, that is the summit that may educate you ways. Right here’s the schedule to see if any displays are interesting to you:

Journey Summit Schedule

Use my affiliate code “MILLENNIAL” to get $50 off your ticket right here (simply kind “MILLENNIAL” into the “coupon” subject on the “Take a look at” web page):


Hope to see you there!



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments